
The Pro Evolution Soccer series has survived because of one thing – it simulates the game of soccer really, really well. Although there was a bit of a hiccup with PES 6, with Konami leaving out half the leagues and the ability to edit teams, players and strips, it still outshone its competitors last year.
This year I want to compare PES 2008 with its main competitor, and it’s not FIFA 2008. What made me think this was a friend’s younger son who is soccer mad and absolutely loves Adelaide United (Go You Reds!). He is so excited about being able to play the A-League that even though I tried to tell him PES was a superior game, he just wouldn’t have it. To him it wasn’t better because it didn’t have the A-League. Sure, you can edit player and team names and stats, scan in team badges, and so on, but that’s “too much messing around”. And he’s right. People don’t play FIFA because it’s the superior soccer game; they play it because it’s got all the teams and players’ people love, straight out of the box.
So, to me PES 2008 biggest competitor is actually PES 6. Because PES has superior gameplay, as long as they don’t tinker with the game what is there to encourage you to buy the latest version? Well thankfully a lot. PES 2008 addresses nearly all my issues with the previous incarnation of the game. Yet there are still a number of issues to be found here, making it far from perfect.
As always, PES truly shines in its Master League. This year is no exception. With more teams and leagues on offer than the previous year, the depth is even more remarkable. You can jump in with the ‘default’ team, and this will provide quite the challenge. You’ll really have to pay attention to the way the team works together, and take advantage of transfers to bolster your side else you simply won’t progress far.
Selecting a good team makes the season easier, but it’s still no walk in the park. Even with a team like Barcelona it’s still a very challenging game.
Part of the reason is the new adaptive AI called ‘TeamVision’. Apparently designed for PES 2008, the AI team will learn your plays and adapt to your tactics, and does so pretty admirably. I found that if I was constantly attacking down the left wing, my players would be shut down. This in turn makes you adjust your style of play. I tend to always counter attack hard down the wings, but found myself playing the middle and controlling the ball, drawing fouls and slowing down the pace. It’s nice when you realise you’re learning from a game.
If anything has changed, it’s the amount of scoring that occurs. In PES 6 I had a string of nil-all draws. PES 2008 has a higher score line, but it’s never unrealistic. And given the score lines in real matches in the EPL this year, I have to take my hat off to Konami for being so accurate. This doesn’t make the game easier to beat either; working to score a goal, and preventing the AI score in return, is still as difficult as ever. It’s just you’ll tend to have 1-all draws instead of nil-all draws.
One addition that raised eyebrows when announced is diving and shirt pulling. Some people see this as a travesty; I see it as a more accurate representation of the game, as sad as that is. However, it doesn’t have a great impact on the gameplay itself. I’ve only managed it a few times as the button combo isn’t the easiest to pull off, and only seen the AI do it a few times. Plus it’s funny to take a dive, especially in the penalty area.
Graphically the game is good up to a point. Playing the game is fine, with the players looking good, crowds looking adequate, and the interface is much slicker than previous years. Gone are the unlabelled, obscure menu icons, replaced with simple descriptive words. Saving is done by highlighting “Save”. However, there is a real problem with replays. When watching the replay action after getting a foul or scoring a goal the frame rate takes a big dive and looks like slow motion. Playing back recorded replays is fine, and it’s unnoticeable if you skip the replays, but the fact it’s there is troubling.
Sound wise the game is a massive improvement over last year. There’s a variety of music now, some of it even quite enjoyable, although I think most of it was created especially for the game. They don’t even tell you the artist of the track, just the genre, which range from rock to drum and bass, but they’re pretty loose definitions of those genres. The game sound like being at a soccer stadium, but the commentary does tend to repeat itself far too often.
I mentioned Team and Player editing earlier, and it’s found its way back into the game. You can edit everything from the position of the badge on the strip, amount of colours on the team strip, position of numbers on the shorts, and everything in between. You can use the Xbox Live Vision cam to take shots of your favourite teams logo and make them more true to life. You can even import your own face, although the lack of editing tools and low quality of the camera make that more trouble than it’s really worth. If you plan on doing this, make sure you’ve got good lighting.
You can share your options with a friend if you have a memory card, though missing is the ability to share these over Xbox Live. Lacking the patience to do this myself, I would have loved the option of sharing another’s option file. I understand why this was left out though – I don’t think Konami would like to have their name sullied because some childish soccer hooligan decided to remake Chelsea with penises on the foreheads.
Speaking of Live, avoid playing this online. I’ve played a couple of games and the lag was terrible. Admittedly I’m on a slower connection now, but I’ve played other fact action games without a hiccup. This was unplayable – players warping around, goals missed as the lag tried to catch up, it was just a horrible, horrible experience. I prefer playing PES against someone in the same room, and it’s great for getting a bunch of buddies around, but avoid online play until there’s a patch.
Conclusion:
The simple fact of the matter is Pro Evolution Soccer 2008 should have been released last year. PES 6 for Xbox 360 was a gimped version of PES 6 for Playstation 2. This year we get the full game, and it’s still PES, but that works for and against it. Yes, it’s still got the awesome soccer feel. Yes, it’s controller breakingly frustrating to play at times. Yes, it’s got the ability to edit teams and players now.
But still, it feels a bit like we’re getting the same game over and over. Like the Tony Hawk series, it’s beginning to feel stale. There’s nothing extraordinarily different in terms of the actual gameplay despite the ‘TeamVision’, and he flaws it does have – the slow down in replays, the terrible online play, indicate that maybe Konami are starting to rest on their laurels slightly.
Pros:
Excellent simulation of the beautiful game
Scoring goals takes is easier, but overall play is still challenging.
Long and deep Master League.
Create your own leagues.
Ability to edit teams, players and strips is great for the fans of real clubs.
Greatly improved music.
Cons
Steep learning curve could put off players of other sports games.
Extremely laggy when playing online.
Should have allowed sharing of edited teams over Xbox Live.
Commentary gets repetitive.
85/100
