Pro Evolution Soccer used to be king of the hill when it came to soccer games. FIFA, whilst glitzy and loaded with cash, couldn’t match PES for the realism and all the fun of the World Game on a home console. However, starting with the2009 versions of the games (which were actually out in 2008), we saw the tables turn, with PES playing catch up ever since. This year is no different, but the gap has closed significantly.

It begins with the 360 passing. Quick and effective passing is what soccer is all about, and whilst it’s been good in PES in the past, it needed work. It always felt in PES that players were glued to the ball and running down invisible bits of string, with passing being based on algorithms and logic, instead of timing and forethought. However, it’s changed now to be much more flexible, and indeed harder. Now there is a power meter as well as the ability to send the ball in any direction. You must practice and get used to it, otherwise you’ll feel like passing has devolved. It wasn’t until I realised holding the trigger modifies the passing allowing you to target the ball better that I began to understand why I was passing through balls instead of passing succinctly.

This year’s game is played at a slower pace than what most PES players would be used to, but this is an improvement to the realism of the game. It complements the new passing moves and the new power meter. This makes the game slightly more tactical, which means the “ping-pong” action of the game, always a criticism of PES, almost doesn’t exist any longer.

PES 2011 retains the card modifiers for star players, and for the most part works well. Messi, although a great player, doesn’t have superpowers in real life, and the card modifiers for him don’t make him unstoppable. They add an increased depth to the way the player AI handles certain situations, but there is never a sense these star players are overpowered, just good at the game.

However, the improvements are let down somewhat by the AI and ball physics. To explain my complaints with the AI, it’s best to use examples. On a run up the field with a defending player, such as Puyol, players will do a dead stop rather than run offside. However, forwards are always faster than defenders, so this means if you dribble past the line of defence, your players will be at a standstill at some points and not running up into support. Conversely, when you’re defending, your players will run back from the player with the ball, meaning they’ll lose their marks, allowing attackers into the goal square.

Ball physics still needs a lot of work, as I’ve seen the ball bounce off a player into touch at right angles to that player, who was facing away from the direction of play. I’ve also seen a corner being headed directly upwards, which then neatly fell at the player’s feet which was volleyed into the goal. Whilst it makes the game more unpredictable, and in some ways a lot of fun, there are times when the bounce can put you at an extreme disadvantage. Particularly true is near the end of the match, when your players are tired. Last minute goals which end up in tied or lost matches are far too common in PES to be put down to simple luck.

There are plenty of modes of offer, with the Champions League and Copa Santander Libertadores (South American League) being playable, as well as being able to form your own leagues and competitions. The Master League is still incredibly in depth, seeming to take more from football manager games but applying it to how you manage your club. The menus are less obtuse and confusing than before, making it easy to get in and edit tactics, team formations, individual positions, man marking and the like. However, leaving it all to the “coach” also works just as well as getting your fingers dirty with the minutia of PES Master League.

This year the Master League goes online, and I have to be honest and say I never really gave it much of a go. I like being able to jump online, play a game, and then forget about it. If I wanted to manage teams in an in depth fashion, I’d play an online football manager. However, the few games I did have were pretty good compared to my experiences in previous years. There was an awfully long wait to get to a game, but once in it was only a little laggy, and certainly not unplayable as PES has been in the past.

The Be a Pro – sorry “Become a Legend” mode introduced a few years ago is back, but it still feels like a terrible rip off of FIFA’s mode. There’s still no ongoing notification of how you are performing during a match, which makes it very hard to develop your Legend. Personally, I think they should drop this mode and concentrate on the team game, which has always been one of PES’s strong points.

This is one of the best looking PES games in years. On field animation is great, especially with the teams licensed for the game. Other teams don’t fare so well and at times some players look a little stiff, robotic and bowlegged. Replays look fantastic, as there is a motion blur applied to the camera, and you can see players heads follow the ball as it whizzes past them. The crowd animation is still poor, and it lacks the vitality of other sports games. The ability to modify teams and now stadiums is a welcome addition, but it still feels silly to call the teams North London and Pompy.

The sound is great, for the most part too. The players call out to each other, and the authentic crowd chants and drum beating capture the authenticity of a real soccer match where the animation doesn’t. The music this year is great – no weird no-name Japanese trying to be westerners pop, but actual licensed music from Elite Force and Shihad, amongst others. However, this too is let down by the commentary. Dull, repetitive, and often not following the course of play at all. I don’t think it’s particularly the fault of John Champion and Jim Beglin, but more so the way commentary is arranged and triggered.

Conclusion:
To be brutally frank, in the preceding years PES seemed wishy washy, unsure of itself in light of the more powerful FIFA. This year, they’ve gone back to the drawing board, worked out what PES did well, what FIFA does well, and tried to make the better game. They succeeded in making a better PES, but it’s not the best football game available this year. In essence, it’s a poor man’s FIFA.

And whilst calling PES 2011 a “poor man’s FIFA” may be an insult to long term PES players, I think it’s a very admirable quality to have. Konami don’t have the teams and Leagues EA can secure, don’t have the resources to dedicate to upgrading and improving the game and engine like EA can, nor even supply as good a commentary or soundtrack as EA, but even so PES 2011 is a damn impressive attempt at a fun soccer game.

Pros:
Great new passing mechanism
Incredibly in depth Master League
Master League can now be played against others online.
Relatively lag free online play

Cons:
Bad commentary
Still has some AI issues
Ball physics still feel unrealistic and unpredictable
Some dodgy player animations

81/100

When I played Pro Evolution Soccer for the first time about 3 years, I was instantly sold on it. Sure, the game had funny names for teams and players, and the presentation was poor, but none of that mattered because the gameplay on the pitch was so good. It was the first time I felt like I was playing a game of soccer that closely replicated the actual physical game. The player’s skill numbers actually felt like they meant something, the team play was terrific, and the game felt responsive and fun.

But oh my, how the mighty fall. PES 09 doesn’t feel like the same series I fell in love with 3 years ago. Although there have been some improvements in getting real teams and players and adding some new modes, the actual game itself seems to have suffered as a result. Although it’s on the same engine as it has been for the last 3 years, there is an enormous gap of quality between PES 6 and PES 09.

The first thing I noticed which has changed for the worse is the team play. I can’t understand why it has changed, but players seem to flock around the ball rather than play the field. They’re often out of position or worse, get in one another’s way. This is particularly true of defence, and it means the opposition will find holes in your defence more often than they should. Players no longer make decent runs, or will run straight into opposition players instead of seeking out open space.

Passing has changed so now you hold the A button for longer passes. This is a good idea on paper, but let down by poor implementation. Often a player will run to the ball, but it will suddenly decide it can’t get their and stop their run. And I mean stop to a complete standstill while another player gets the ball, or to simply watch the ball go out of bounds. PES has always played along the 8 directions of the joypad, but now it seems if the ball and player aren’t lined up completely, the game gives the ball up.

Worse still is the physics. The ball now simply doesn’t feel right. The ball feels ultra heavy – it will stop dead far sooner than it’s meant to, meaning through balls feel wasted most of the time. And although PES has always had a problem with the ball bouncing off players, now it seems even worse. Players scramble over the balls, with the ball bouncing off players like a pinball.

Then there’s the issue PES always has had that still haven’t been addressed. Like throw-ins, where the opposition has an exclusion zone preventing the player from positioning and pressuring during the throw. FIFA 09 allows players to jostle during thrown balls, and this artifice of PES makes it seem really outdated. Also trying to score from free kicks still feels as pointless as ever. Yes, you can score, but the ability to get it right still feels like luck instead of skill. And turning kicks at goals still fly over the bar every time, no matter how much or how little power you apply.

It’s not all bad, and you will still experience some of the brilliance of the former games. Although crosses seem a little weaker, volleys still look and feel awesome when they smash into the back of the net. The pace is brisker than FIFA, yet measured. Results are still far more realistic. Although 5-nil games aren’t unheard of in PES, the occurrence isn’t nearly as frequent as FIFA, even when playing on the easier settings.

PES 09 has secured the rights of the UEFA Championship League, which is quite the coup. You can choose to play this league right off the main menu, and like previous titles, the league mode is as great as ever. You will get sick of hearing the UEFA music though. And PES still has the better manager mode, and once you get into it, the deep gameplay will have you rapt. The player improvement and transfers and all the other things which make this mode great are still in place. And now even the menu system is slightly less convoluted as before! PES also has the better method of displaying of team and player stats, meaning you can tell how good a team is and where a player’s strength lies just by looking at the skill pentagram. This is far better than FIFAs 100 points system.

A new mode to tackle FIFA Be A Pro, introduced in last years FIFA, is Become A Legend. Like FIFA, you control one player and run them through their career. Unlike FIFA, you’re not limited by their seasons, but by their age, which means you can play your pro until retirement at age 35. However, it is the much poorer cousin to FIFA’s excellent offering. You will play many squad v squad matches in order to get to you main team, and these are just on the training pitch with no crowd and no commentary. Realistic, probably, but quite boring in actuality. You can skip these, but then you don’t get XP to expand the player.

You’re rewarded for the way you play like FIFA, but there’s absolutely no feedback on the pitch. It assumes you know the sport. Of course if you have poor positioning like offsides, slide too much and get carded you, you will get a bad rating, but if you don’t know much about soccer, you’re going to get a little lost. To help, holding the left bumper makes player go into position, but some sort of onscreen direction would be preferable.
The online system is sort of weird. You sign into servers which show how many people are playing, then from there look for a quick game or ranked match. It feels a little awkward. Unfortunately I’ve only managed to have one game against a friend, although it was much better than PES 08, being smoother with far less lag, it was no where near the quality of FIFA 09’s online connections.

The game looks and sounds like PES has for the last 3 years. Menus are a little cleaner and more intuitive, but not by much. The players look a little better, but I think the player animations on field have gotten worse. I’ve seen players animate for a big kick even though I simply moved the joystick left or right. I’ve also seen the ball pass through a players legs, and it looked like all the animations played at once with the player spazzing out. However, other animations look cool, like when players automatically spin past other players.

Sound wise the music once again is what the Japanese developers think is “cool” amongst soccer fans at the moment. None of it is by any recognisable group, and although it’s not completely terrible, it’s not fantastic by any means. Commentary is almost exactly the same as last year. There is a little more banter played at the end of the game and after goals and goal chances, but it gets repetitive really quickly.

Conclusion:
PES has always been the little game that could. It’s faced the might of EA and delivered a soccer game that has been superior for most of its lifetime. However, lately EA seem to have suddenly “got” what players want, and have dished up a mighty fine game in FIFA 09. On the other hand Konami have seemed to rest on their laurels, and for possibly the first time have dropped the ball and seen FIFA take the win.

PROS
– UEFA Champions League mode
– The usual deep Manager Mode
– Still a good game of soccer
– Less lag than previous PES titles.

CONS
– Team play, ball physics and passing seem to have gotten worse
– Become a Legend mode doesn’t show any on screen help during play
– No other real improvements to the game
– Commentary gets repetitive really quickly

79/100